INTEGRATED COURSE PROJECT

From gas in place
to a justified decision.

A fictional shale appraisal block brings the twelve lectures together. Work through the inputs and tasks, then compare your reasoning with the complete solution.

Open lecture 12 →

Scenario: Fictional shale appraisal block

You are advising whether an appraisal block warrants further investigation. It is a teaching case, not a named real field. Prepare a 4–6 page report, or an equivalent Markdown report, with calculations, two simple plots, and a justified recommendation.

Use the entire block consistently: the volume estimates and the production model below refer to the same project area, and the supplied rate is the project's total rate, not the rate of every individual well.

Input Value
Area, \(A\) 1.0 km²
Net thickness, \(h\) 20 m
Consistent free-gas porosity, \(\phi\) 0.06
Water saturation, \(S_w\) 0.30
Initial \(B_g\) 0.005 reservoir m³/standard m³
Dry bulk density 2,400 kg/m³ of bulk rock
Initial reservoir pressure 15 MPa absolute
Langmuir volume, \(V_L\) 2.0 standard m³/t of dry bulk rock
Langmuir pressure, \(P_L\) 5.0 MPa absolute
Screening recovery factor 0.25 of total initial gas
Fixed total stress for the stress exercise 40 MPa
Biot coefficient 1.0
Later pore pressure for the stress exercise 7 MPa absolute
Project production model, \(q_i\) 200,000 standard m³/day
Project production model, \(D\) 0.003 day⁻¹
Production calculation interval Day 0 to day 365; no earlier production
Initial project investment 5.0 million currency units
End-of-year net cash flows, years 1–3 2.0, 2.5, and 2.0 million currency units
Annual discount rate 10%

Model assumptions: No oil or hydrate in the modeled pores. Porosity, saturation, and absolute adsorbed inventory are supplied on compatible bases so the additive model does not count the same gas twice. Hold other inputs fixed during the requested sensitivities. The three-year cash flows are an independently supplied economic scenario, already net of all modeled costs; do not derive them from the one-year production curve. These simplifications support learning, not a complete development model.

Tasks

  1. C01 — Free gas: Calculate gas-filled pore volume and initial free gas in standard m³.
  2. C02 — Adsorbed gas: Calculate dry rock mass in metric tonnes, initial equilibrium gas content, and initial adsorbed inventory.
  3. C03 — Screening recovery: Sum the storage inventories and apply the assumed recovery factor. Explain what the result does and does not establish.
  4. C04 — Stress: Calculate initial and later effective stress under the specified fixed-total-stress assumption. Explain one possible effect on flow.
  5. C05 — Production: Calculate day-365 rate and cumulative gas through day 365. Plot rate versus time and cumulative gas versus time at 0, 90, 180, 270, and 365 days. Compare cumulative gas with C03.
  6. C06 — Storage sensitivity: Recalculate free and total gas for a low case, \(\phi=0.04\), \(S_w=0.40\), and a high case, \(\phi=0.08\), \(S_w=0.20\). Keep the adsorbed inventory and other inputs fixed. Apply the same recovery factor and compare with the unchanged production model. Explain any inconsistency.
  7. C07 — Economics: Calculate base-case NPV. Recalculate it if an additional water-management cost of 0.5 million occurs at the end of year 1.
  8. C08 — Recommendation: Recommend further appraisal, conditional development, or rejection. Justify your choice using the calculations, three missing measurements, and three environmental controls. Explain why the exercise cannot establish reportable reserves.

AFTER YOU HAVE TRIED THE TASKS

Complete solutions and assessment guide

Worked solution

C01 — Free gas

Net bulk volume is \(10^6(20)=20\times10^6\) m³. Gas-filled pore volume is:

\[ V_{pg}=20\times10^6(0.06)(0.70)=840{,}000\ \mathrm{reservoir\ m^3} \]
\[ G_f=\frac{840{,}000}{0.005}=168\times10^6\ \mathrm{standard\ m^3} \]

C02 — Adsorbed gas

\[ M=\frac{20\times10^6(2{,}400)}{1{,}000} =48\times10^6\ \mathrm{t} \]
\[ C_{\mathrm{ads},i}=2\frac{15}{5+15} =1.5\ \mathrm{standard\ m^3/t} \]
\[ G_{\mathrm{ads},i}=48\times10^6(1.5) =72\times10^6\ \mathrm{standard\ m^3} \]

The case explicitly supplies compatible free-phase and absolute adsorption definitions. In real work, check whether adsorption occupies volume already assigned to free gas; also distinguish absolute adsorption from measured excess adsorption.

C03 — Total and screening recovery

\(G_{\mathrm{total}}=168+72=240\) million standard m³. At the assumed recovery factor, \(G_{\mathrm{rec}}=240(0.25)=60\) million standard m³.

This is a screening estimate under assumptions. It is not a validated technical recovery model, a forecast schedule, or a reserve booking.

C04 — Effective stress

Initially \(\sigma'=40-15=25\) MPa. Later \(\sigma'=40-7=33\) MPa. Under the specified fixed-total-stress assumption, effective compressive stress rises by 8 MPa, potentially reducing pore/fracture openings and conductivity. The calculation alone cannot quantify that change.

C05 — Production

\[ q_g(365)=200{,}000e^{-0.003(365)} \approx66{,}908\ \mathrm{standard\ m^3/day} \]
\[ G_p(365)=\frac{200{,}000-66{,}907.9}{0.003} \approx44.364\times10^6\ \mathrm{standard\ m^3} \]
Day Project rate, standard m³/day Cumulative gas, million standard m³
0 200,000.0 0.000
90 152,675.9 15.775
180 116,549.7 27.817
270 88,971.6 37.009
365 66,907.9 44.364

The one-year cumulative is below the base-case 60 million screening recovery estimate. It represents about 73.9% of that estimate. This basic check does not validate either model.

For optional discussion, extending the exponential model to infinite time gives \(q_i/D=66.667\) million standard m³, exceeding the 60 million screening quantity. A finite rate/economic limit or revised recovery/production model is therefore needed for an internally consistent lifetime assessment. Matching one year does not establish matching lifetime recovery.

C06 — Sensitivity

Case \(\phi\) \(S_w\) Free gas, million standard m³ Adsorbed gas Total gas At \(RF=0.25\)
Low 0.04 0.40 96 72 168 42
Base 0.06 0.30 168 72 240 60
High 0.08 0.20 256 72 328 82

The unchanged production model produces 44.364 million standard m³ by day 365, exceeding the low-case 42 million screening recoverable quantity. Those assumptions cannot all stand as a consistent recoverable-production scenario. Review storage, recovery factor, forecast, and stopping criteria; do not simply label the excess a rounding error.

These are deterministic scenarios, not probabilistically defined P90/P50/P10 estimates. Holding adsorption constant isolates the requested sensitivity and does not model every geological correlation.

C07 — Economics

In millions of currency units:

\[ NPV_{\mathrm{base}}=-5+\frac{2}{1.1}+ \frac{2.5}{1.1^2}+\frac{2}{1.1^3} =0.386927 \]
\[ NPV_{\mathrm{extra\ water\ cost}} =0.386927-\frac{0.5}{1.1} =-0.067618 \]

The additional cost occurs at year-end 1, so discount it once; do not subtract it as a time-zero cost. A modest positive base NPV is sensitive to this specified downside.

The supplied economics are independent of the one-year decline illustration. Do not claim a gas price, a well count, or a three-year production schedule was calculated from that illustration.

C08 — Example recommendation

“Proceed to targeted further appraisal before committing to full development. Base-case storage and the supplied economics are encouraging, but the downside water-cost case has negative NPV and the low storage case conflicts with the unchanged production forecast. Prioritize stress-dependent core/relative-permeability measurements, pressure and production testing, and calibrated gas-content/adsorption data; also assess containment and water compatibility. Require a water-management plan, verified well barriers, and methane detection/repair with follow-up measurement. Commerciality, project definition, and reporting criteria remain insufficient to establish reserves.”

Alternative decisions are acceptable if supported by the supplied evidence, explicit criteria, and uncertainty.

Project marking rubric

Criterion Raw marks
C01: Correct volume basis, pore volume, and free-gas calculation 12
C02: Correct mass basis, Langmuir content, and adsorbed inventory 12
C03: Total, screening recovery, and terminology 10
C04: Effective stress and qualified interpretation 8
C05: Rate/cumulative calculations, labeled plots, base-case comparison 16
C06: Low/high calculations and consistency discussion 14
C07: NPV timing, arithmetic, and sensitivity interpretation 14
C08: Reasoned recommendation, missing data, controls, reserves limitation 10
Clear assumptions, units, and references throughout 4
Total 100

For calculations, assign approximately half the credit to method and units. For C08, award credit for evidence-based reasoning rather than for choosing one preferred recommendation.